Tempe's Unknown Congressman,
John R. Murdock

In the 1930's, Tempe could claim two-
John Robert Murdock was born April 20, 1885 [1] near Lewistown, in Lewis County,
Missouri. [2] He was the fourth child, and the first son of John and Elizabeth
Murdock, who operated a farm in homestead Township. [3] His father, 17 years older
than his mother, died in 1899, [4] leaving 14-
In 1904, at the age of 19, John began teaching school. Needing more education, he
enrolled at the First District Normal School (now Truman State Univ-
In 1914, John was hired by President John A. Matthews of the Tempe Normal School of Arizona (now Arizona State University) to teach history and government to aspiring teachers. It is odd to note that Murdock, with a Bachelor of Arts degree, had more education than Matthews, who had left Syracuse University during his junior year. [11]
Murdock quickly became an important part of Arizona education. In addition to training hundreds of teachers, he coached softball, [12] and he was the author of history texts, Arizona Characters in Silhouette, History Outline; Arizona and Southwestern History, and government textbooks, The Constitution of Arizona, Constitutional Development of Arizona, and with Austin Repp, A Work and Study Book for Students on the Constitutional Development of Arizona. During this period, his third son, John Benjamin

was delivered by future governor, Dr. Benjamin B. Moeur on June 12, 1919. [13] In 1933, Murdock became a Dean of the college, now called Arizona State Teacher's College at Tempe .[14]
Murdock lived the quiet life of a college professor with one notable exception. His neighbors, the Nevitt family, who lived behind him, obtained a pair of Muscovey ducks to breed, with the idea of selling the hatchlings so that other people could have Muscovey ducks.
Maud Nevitt Olsen relates:
Early one morning, Professor Murdock saw one of the ducks taking flight. He rushed
into his house and grabbed the 30-
and killed the duck. In the act of shooting at the duck, he shot toward the Baker's house. They were really frightened, as the bullet
went through the house. Luckily no one was killed or wounded. Realizing what he had done, Mr. Murdock rushed and apologized to
Dad. After a lengthy conversation, he wrote a check for the duck and gave it to Dad. He stated that he couldn't explain why he did such a stupid thing.
He was very sorry. This episode ended Dad's duck business. [15]
In 1936, Arizona's lone Congressional Representative, Isabella Greenway, decided
not to seek another term. Deciding to put his govern-
Ten men and one woman declared themselves candidates for the Democratic nomination. In the beginning of the campaign, State Senator Nellie Bush, who had supplied the “Arizona Navy” when Governor Moeur tried to stop the construction of Parker Dam, was considered the front runner. She characterized herself as the “best man for the job.” [19] Also, highly regarded was Phoenix Judge M. T. Phelps, who had the support of the Townsend Club, a group who wanted lavish pensions for retirees. [20] Murdock defeated his closest rival, Phelps, by 2,418 votes. Nellie Bush ran a poor third. [21]
Getting the Democratic nomination was tantamount to being elected in pre-

Representative Murdock joined the 75th congress as a supporter of Roosevelt's New Deal. Although the 1937 New Deal was more in line with Murdock's idea of a “conservative liberal” [23] than the first New Deal, he was still bewildered at the emphasis on spending, rather than balancing the budget. [24] However, he soon joined the spenders by seeking a bill to aid handicapped children, [25] supporting sanitation projects for Arizona, building tennis courts in Parker, [26] and voting for the Townsend plan to give a $200 monthly pension to the aged. [27] With Senator Carl Hayden, he sought government funding for the Gila project to bring Colorado River water to the lower Gila valley. [28] Also, as a member of the Western Bloc's Committee on Mining, [29] Murdock worked to protect mining rights, [30] especially those of the small miners. [31]
In the 1938 Democratic primary, Murdock defeated James Moore. [32] Both candidates
ran as supporters of the New Deal. [33] Murdock over-
Representative Murdock continued his support of the New Deal in the 76th Congress. He maintained his efforts to obtaining Arizona's share of Colorado River water for the Gila River farmers. [35] In addition, he supported these farmers, who were large producers of alfalfa seed, by backing the tariffs on imported seed. [36] He continued working for aid to miners by helping to draft legislation to grant loans to small mines. [37] Murdock anticipated Franklin Roosevelt's call for the United States to be an “arsenal of democracy” [38] by advocating that the United States support the forces opposing Hitler in Europe by selling them arms.
His program differed from Roosevelt's by proposing to give all profits from arms sales to the U. S. Treasury. [39]
John Murdock's most controversial vote was against a bill to deport labor leader Harry Bridges. [40] Bridges was the leader of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union. He was born in Australia, and had never obtained American citizenship. He had openly used Communist Party assistance for his labor activities, and he was suspected of being a Communist Party member, although this was never proven. [41] Because of this, a motion was introduced in Congress to deport him. Murdock voted no, explaining that the bill was unconstitutional because it denied Bridges the right of a writ of habeas corpus, and it was also close to being a bill of attainder. [42]
Murdock's vote sparked protests by civic groups across the state. [43] This may have led to the meeting of Howard Speakman and Ernest McFarland where they decided to challenge Murdock, and longtime senator Henry Ashurst, in the 1940 election. Speakman, who was well known from acting as the judge in the Winnie Ruth Judd murder trial, was to run against Murdock, supposedly, the weaker candidate. McFarland was to run against Ashurst. [44] Speakman's candidacy came to nothing, and Murdock defeated newspaperman William Mathews by over 8,000 votes in the primary election. Surprisingly, McFarland defeated Ashurst by an almost two to one margin. [45] In the general election, Murdock easily defeated Republican K. T. Palmer. [46]
In 1942, Arizona was alloted two seats in the House of Representatives. Eighteen
candidates filed to run in the Democratic primary for the two at-
The entry of the United States into World War II overshadowed most domestic issues.
But, Murdock continued to work for the interests of Arizona farmers. He fought to
give well casings a high priority to the war effort, [50] worked to establish the
growing of Yucca for its fiber, [51] and tried to establish cultivation of the guayule
plant in Arizona to supplement rubber supplies. [52] Guayule was the plant that
the pre-
The realities of the war were intensified when Murdock received news that his eldest son, First Lieutenant David N. Murdock was killed in action on August 11,1943, while fighting in the invasion of Sicily. David died on the first anniversary of his enlistment. [56]
Murdock seemed to violate the respect he had shown the Constitution in the Bridges
case, when he and Carl Hayden asked that the quarantine line restricting Japanese
in Arizona be further extended. This would send more Japanese-
Harless and Murdock easily won re-
With the war close to ending, Arizona's water rights again became an issue. The
Wellton-
Representative Murdock received a letter from Franklin Roosevelt the day before
he died, requesting Murdock to make provisions to give veterans returning from the
war access to reasonable priced irrigated land. [64] He and senator McFarland sponsored
a bill that gave veterans preference on any land that would be opened for settlement
and irrigation by the Gila Canal. [65] Not only did this aid veterans, but it was
important to help pass the legislation for the Wellton-
The 1946 election was a repudiation of the New Deal. The Republicans gained control of the Senate and House of Representatives. Arizona, however, was still solidly Democratic. Democrats Murdock, Harless, and McFarland were returned to office. [66]
Even with a Republican Congress, in July of 1947, the Wellton-
The 1948 election posed a problem for Murdock and Harless. Arizona's House of Representatives seats would no longer be elected at large. [68] They would be elected by districts. Maricopa County was district one, and the rest of the state was district two. [69] The problem was that both Murdock and Harless lived in Maricopa County. Harless considered moving to Safford, his former home in District two. [70} However, he chose not to move, but instead, he challenged Dan Garvey for Governor in the primary election. Garvey became Governor when Sidney P. Osborn died in office. Murdock ran unopposed in the primary, and Insurance Agent Harold Patten was nominated in District Two. Harless lost to Garvey. Again, getting the Democratic nomination ensured victory in the November general election. [71]
With the Democratic party in control of the 81st congress, [72] Arizona's delegation
advanced to powerful positions. Senator Hayden became chairman of the Senate Rules
committee and ranking member on the Appropriations committee, and Murdock became
chairman of the House Sub-

Arizona would need all of the power it could muster. The battle had begun to construct
the Central Arizona Project (CAP). This would bring Colorado River water to the interior
of Arizona. While the Gila Project took 300,000 acre feet of water, [74] the CAP
would divert 1,500,000 acre feet of water, over 5 times the amount taken by Wellton-
In 1950, the demographics of the state were beginning to shift. Democrats Murdock,
Patton, and Hayden won re-
The power of the Arizona congressional delegation increased further when Ernest MacFarland was elected majority leader of the Senate. [78] In spite of these powerful positions of the Arizona delegation, very little progress was made on the CAP. California, with its 23 representatives to the House, continued its fierce opposition. [79] This fight raged for 18 more years, until finally in 1968, the CAP was approved. Construction began in 1973 and was finished in 1993. [80]
In 1952, Murdock faced opposition in the Democratic primary for the first time in several years. His opponent was Ralph Watkins, a Buckeye automobile dealer. Watkins based his opposition on the idea that Murdock was weak on Communism. This was based on Murdock's 1940 vote against deporting Harry Bridges. [81] He was also opposed by Joe Worthy, a Phoenix radio personality. [82] Murdock won the primary election and faced Republican John Rhodes in the general election. President Truman attempted to help Murdock, and also MacFarland, by trying to advance the CAP. [83] In addition, organized labor gave them a strong endorsement. [84] But, the political climate had changed in postwar Arizona. Murdock lost to Rhodes, and MacFarland was defeated by Barry Goldwater. [85] Arizona's power in the U. S. Congress was greatly diminished, and the fight for the CAP now largely depended on Senator Hayden.
After his defeat, Murdock was engaged to lecture on government and history for the summer term at Arizona State College at Flagstaff. After the session, he did not remain in Arizona, but returned to the Washington D. C. area. His wife, Dr. Myrtle Murdock, was hired as a guide at the capitol. She had written several books about the city and its buildings, and was considered to be the leading expert on the subject. [86]
Murdock settled into retirement. In 1960, his former school, now called Arizona State University, recognized his long career and contributions to Arizona, awarded him an honorary Doctor of Laws degree. [87] After a long, quiet retirement, Murdock died in Phoenix, February, 1972, at the age of 86. [88]
While little remembered today, John R. Murdock was responsible for educating thousands of Arizona students in his classes at the college in Tempe, and by his numerous textbooks on Arizona history and government. During his sixteen year tenure in the House of Representatives, spanning the Great Depression, World War II and the postwar recovery period, he earned a reputation as a hard working, effective Congressman who became an expert on water issues. Modern Arizona owes a great debt to John R. Murdock.
Notes
1. Selective Service System of the United States, Maricopa County, Phoenix, Arizona, record number 4542, Sept. 12, 1918.
2. Biographical Index of the United .States congress, http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/diosisplay.pl?Index=M001081.
3. United States Department of Commerce and Labor, Bureau of the Census, Tenth Census of the United States, 1880, Highland
Township, Lewis County, Missouri.
4. Ancstry.com. John Murdock, http://trees.ancestry.com/owt/person.aspx?pid=77445519&st=1
5. United States Department of Commerce and Labor, Bureau of the Census, Twelfth Census of the United States, 1900, Highland
Township, Lewis County, Missouri.
6. Biographical Index of the United States congress, ibid. The date of his graduation is incorrect.
7. Ancestry.con. Family Trees, One World Tree, John R. Murdock, http://trees.ancestry.com/owt/person.aspx?pid=61968275.
8. United States Department of Commerce and Labor, Bureau of the Census, Thirteenth Census of the United States, 1910, Adair
County. Kirksville City, Missouri.
9. Northeast Missouri State Teachers College Alumni Roster, http://http://library.truman.edu/archives/alumni1924L.htm#M
10. United States Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Fourteenth Census of the United State, 1920. Maricopa
County, Tempe, Arizona.
11. Ernest J. Hopkins and Alfred Thomas Jr., The Arizona State University Story, Southwest Publishing Co., Phoenix, Arizona, 1960.
12. Arizona State All-
13. Biographical Index of the United .States congress, ibid.
14. Arizona State Board of Health, Bureau of Vital Statistics, Original Certificate of Birth, John Benjamin Murdock, July 10, 1919.
15. Maude Nevitt Olsen, “Memories of an Old Settler,” Joel A. Benedict, Irene A. Benedict, Elizabeth Hampton James, Memories of
Old Settlers of Tempe, Old Settlers Association, Tempe, Arizona, ND.
16. “Murdock Leads Arizona,” San Antonio Express, San Antonio, Texas, September 10, 1936.
17. “John Nurdock Addresses Club, “ Arizona Republic, Phoenix, Arizona, November 11, 1936.
18. “Judge Stanford Opens Drive in Kingman Speech,” Yuma Daily Sun, Yuma, Arizona, October 7, 1936.
19. “Townsend Plan Candidates Take Washington Vote,” Evening State Standard, Lincoln, Nebraska, September 9, 1936.
20. “Arizona May Kill Polls Precedent in This Election,” Waterloo Daily Courier, Waterloo, Iowa, August 24, 1936.
21. “Kerby Holds Slight Lead Over Simms,” Yuma Weekly Sun, Yuma, September 11, 1936.
22. “All Arizona Goes for F. R.,” The Times, San Mateo, California, November 4, 1936.
23. Mark Hugh Leff, The Limits of Symbolic Reform” Yhr New Deal and Taxation, 1933-
Cambridge, United Kingdom, 1984, p. 204.
24. “A Disillusioned Congressman, The Helena Daily Independent, Helena, Montana, April 3, 1937
25. “Handicapped Children of State Listed,” Yuma Daily Sun, December 26, 1937.
26. “2WPA Projects in Ariz. Approved,” Yuma Daily Sun, January 21, 1938.
27. “Lower House of Congress Defeats Twonsend Old Age Pension Measure 302 to 97,” Yuma Daily Sun, June 1, 1939.
28. “Two Utahns Win Point On Project,” The Ogden Standard Examiner, Ogden, Utah, April 18, 1937, “Rep. Murdock Urges Gila
Appropriation,” Yuma Daily Sun, April 21, 1937, “Murdock will Seek to Have Gila Funds Put Back in Bill,” Yuma Daily Sun,
May 15, 1937, “Plan Battle to Secure Funds for Gila Project; Member Drive,” Yuma Daily Sun, May 17, 1937, , “Map Drive,
Reinstate Gila Item,” Yuma Daily Sun, July 16, 1937, “Murdock Pledges His Continued Aid,” Yuma Daily Sun and Yuma Sentinel,
Yuma, Arizona, November 5, 1937.
29. “Murdock Names Bloc Members,” The Ogden Standard Examiner, January 16, 1937,.
30. “Game Refuge Withdrawal in County Awaits F. R.s Approval,” Yuma Daily Sun, December 21, 1937.
31. “Higher Gold Price Rumrs Hit Capital,” Nevada Mining News, Reno, Nevada, June 13, 1938, “President Okehs Mine
Moratorium,” The Modesto Bee and Daily Herald, Modesto, California, June 29, 1938.
32. “Jones Leads Close Race in Arizona,” Oakland Tribune, Oakland, California, September 14, 1938.
33. “Candidates in Arizona Loyal to New Deal,” The Sheboygan Press, Sheboygan, Wisconsin, August 24, 1938.
34. “Democrats Make Clean Sweep in Arizona, Yuma Daily Sun, November 11, 1938.
35. “Rep. Murdock Leads Successful Fight for Retention of Gila Projectr Fund, “ The Yuma Weekly Sun and the Yuma Examiner,
Yuma, Arizona, March 24, 1939.
36. “Arizona Solon Supports Yuma Farmers in Attack on Reciprocal Treaties,” Yuma Daily Sun, October 20, 1939, “Urges
Opposition to Tariff Cuts on Imports of Seed,” Yuma Daily Sun, October 24, 1939
37 “Aid to Miners,” Nevada Mining Journal, May 22, 1939, “SEC Releases Mine Changes,” Nevada Mining Journal, May 29, 1939,
“Sayd Strategic Minerals Bill Reported Out,” Yuma Daily Sun, September 5, 1940.
38. Franklin Delano Roosevelt, “The Great Arsenal of Democracy,” radio address, December 29, 1940.
39. “Murdock Says Arms Embargo is Aid to Germany,: Yuma Weekly Sun, September 9, 1939.
40. Yuma Daily Sun, June 15, 1940.
41. “Harry Bridges, a Biography,” International Longshore and Warehouse Union, Local 19, Seattle Washington,
http://www.ilwu19.com/history/biography.htm.
42. “Rep Murdock Explains Vote in Bridges Case,” Yuma Daily Sun, June 15, 1940.
43. “Arizonans Protest Murdock Vote Against Deporting Bridges,” Albuquerque Journal, Albuquerque, New Mexico, June 15, 1940.
44. Kel M. Fox, “50 Years in Arizona Politics, The Journal of Arizona History, Vol.
34, pp. 79-
45. “M’Farland, Osborn, Murdock in Lead,” Yuma Daily Sun, September 11, 1940.
46. “Results of Nov. 5, 1941 election in Yuma County, Yuma Weekly Sun, May 30, 1941.
47. “Politics Seen Hit in Wartime,” Ogden Standard Examiner, Ogden, Utah, August 29, 1942.
48. “Gov. Osborn, Harless, Stanford, Hunt, Foster, Betts, Brush hold Leads,” Yuma Daily Sun, September 9, 1942.
49. “How Arizona Voted,” Tucsn Daily Citizen, November 4, 1942.
50. “Murdock Asks Well Casing Priority,” Tucson Daily Citizen, February 10, 1942.
51. “Yucca May be Used to Manufacture Rope, Tucson Daily Citizen, June 18, 1943, L. T. Easley, “Texans in Washington, “ The
Brownsville Herald, Brownsville, Texas, November 11, 1941.
52. “Murdock Urges Guayule Planting in Arizona,” Tucson Daily Citizen, February 1, 1942.
52. D. T. Ray, “Guayule, a Source of Natural Rubber,” New Crops, J. Janick and J. E. Simon, eds., Wiley, New York, 1995, p. 338.
54. “Grazing Permit payments are Sought in Bill,” Tucson Daily Citizen, June 19, 1942.
55. “Loans for Mining War Minerals are Sought,” Tucson Daily Citizen, November 20, 1942.
56. “Rep. Murdock’s Son Killed in Action, Aug. 11,” Yuma Daily Sun, September 10, 1942.
57. “Sen. Hayden Asks Army Control Japs in State,” Yuma Daily Sun, July 14, 1943.
58. “Official Canvass of Arizona Votes Shows Roosevelt at 80, 926 Votes to 56, 287 for Dewey in Nov. 7 Election,” Yuma Daily
Sun, November 28, 1944. Harless received 89, 691 votes to Murdock’s 88, 532 votes.
59. “Un-
60. Drew Pearson, “OPA Bill Not Liked by Senators,” Abilene Reporter-
61. United States Bureau of Reclamation, “Dams, Projects & Powerplants, Gila Project,” Arizona, http://www.usbr.gov/dataweb.
html/gila.html#development.
62. Boulder Canyon Project Act, of 1928, pursuant to section 4 of the Act of June 25, 1910 (36 stat. 836) and subsection B of the Act
of December 5, 1924 (43 stat. 701).
63. “House Beats Down Western Efforts to Increase Reclamation Funds, Yuma Daily Sun, May 15, 1946, “Two Congressmen Join
Fight Against Wellton-
Daily Sun, September 24, 1946, “Murdock Fears Gila Bill halted in Congress,” Yuma Daily Sun, July 23, 1946, “California is
Blamed for Stymied Gila Plan, Fresno Bee, Fresno, California, July 25, 1946,
“R. H. MCEllancey Charges Hearings on Wellton-
Mohawk Project Were Prolonged to Deprive Ariz. Of Water,” Yuma Daily Sun, July 23, 1946.
64. “Action Needed to Aid Veterans to Buy Farms,” Modesto Bee and News-
65. “Rep. Murdock Explains Provisions of Gila Project Land Settlement Bill: Veterans Get First Choice,” Yuma Weekly Sun and the
Weekly Reporter, Yuma, March 1, 1946.
66. “Membership of the 80th Congress of the United States,” http://borzoiblog.com/80th.htm
67. August L. Steen, “Gila Bill Passes, Wellton-
68. “Harless hasn’t Yet Chosen Future Home,” Tucson Daily Citizen, July 17, 1947.
69. “Arizona Returns,” Tucson Daily Citizen, November 3, 1948.
70. “Membership of the 81st Congress of the United States,” http://borzoiblog.com/81st.htm.
71. “Arizona Congressmen Advance, “ Tucson Daily Citizen, November 6, 1948.
72. United States Bureau of Reclamation, Dams, Projects & Powerplants, Gila Project, Arizona, http://www.usbr.gov/dateb/ The total
deliveries were later reduced to 280,000 acre feet.
73. “CAP Water Deliveries,” http://www.cap-
74. “House Group Opens Hearing on C. A. Project,” Yuma Daily Sun, March 30, 1949, Imperial Valley Engineer Says USBR Ingored
Contract,” Yuma Daily Sun, June 2, 1949, “Drafter of Upper Colorado Pact Reassures
California,” Long Beach Press-
Long Beach, California, March 16, 1949, “California For of Arizona Project Urges Fresh Delay, “ Tucson Daily Citizen, January
13, 1950, et. Al.
75. “Jewel Jordan Polled Highest Number of Votes in Election,” Tucson Daily Citizen, November 27, 1950.
76. “Membeship of the 82nd Congress of the United States,” http://borzoiblog.com/82nd.htm
77. “Arizona Water Bill Set for March 20,” Oxnard Press Courier, Oxnard, California, March 7, 1950, “Opponents Set to Kill Water
for Arizona, Oxnard Press-
78. CAP, Central Arizona project, History, http://www.cap-
79. “Watkins Hurls Red Charge,” Tucson Daily Citizen, September 3, 1952.
80. Yuma Daily Sun, September 9, 1952.
81. Ray tucker, “Views Behind the News,” San Mateo Times, San mateo, California, August 22, 1952.
82. “CIO Endorses Only 2 of GOP,” Tucson Daily Citizen, August 25, 1952.
83. “State Returns,” Tucson Daily Citizen, November 5, 1952.
84. “AWoman for the 21st Century Born in 1885, Myrtle Cheney Murdock,” Tempe Historical Society Examiner, Winter, 2007
85. Tucson Daily Citizen, June 6, 1960.
86. “Former Solon Dies,” Modesto Bee and News-